The Sufi Conspiracy

Having lost touch with its glorious heritage of classical scholarship, the Muslim world today is divided in squabbles between two opposing camps, who despite their respective deviations, are both attempting to usurp the right to represent orthodox Islam. The Wahhabis and Salafis are the product of a British strategy to undermine Islamic tradition and create fundamentalism. While the Sufis are their most vocal and articulate critics, rightly pointing out their corruptions, they themselves are part of a similar conspiracy, again with close ties to Western intelligence and the occult.

The New Age movement, following the teachings of a leading disciple of H. P. Blavatsky, believes that the coming of the Age of Aquarius will herald the beginning of world peace and one-world government, headed by the Maitreya, who is said to be awaited also by Christians, Jews, Buddhists, Hindus and Muslims, though he is known by these believers respectively as Christ, Messiah, the fifth Buddha, Krishna or Imam Mahdi. The New Age’s expectation of the Mahdi awaited by the Muslims has been nurtured through its relationship with Sufism.

Essentially, the pretext of the occult is that in the future the world will be united in peace by eliminating all sectarianism, when the world will be brought together under a single belief system. The basis of that belief will be the occult tradition, which it is claimed has been the underlying source of all exoteric religions. As such, since at least the middle of the eighteenth century, occultists have marketed Sufism as being the origin of Freemasonry.

According to Idries Shah, the twelfth century Qadiriyya Sufi order was the origin of the Rosicrucians, the most important occult movement after the Renaissance, who later evolved into the Freemasons. As detailed in Black Terror White Soldiers, the Rosicrucians were responsible for orchestrating the advent of Sabbatai Zevi, who took the Jewish world by storm in 1666 when he declared himself their expected messiah. However, Zevi disappointed the vast majority of his followers when he subsequently converted to Islam. Nevertheless, an important segment followed him into Islam as well, and to this day consist of a powerful community of secret Jews known as Dönmeh.

The Dönmeh of Turkey maintained associations with a number of Sufi orders, like Whirling Dervishes founded by Jalal ad-Din Rumi, and the Bektashis. Strongly heretical, the Bektashi venerated Ali, the son-in-law of the Prophet Mohammed, repudiated many of the legal rulings of Islam, and combined Kabbalistic ideas with elements of ancient Central Asian shamanism.

Through the influence of Bektashi Sufism, the Dönmeh developed the belief of Pan-Turkism, later adopted by the Young Turks, a Dönmeh and Masonic organization responsible for overthrowing the Ottoman Caliphate in 1908. Pan-Turkism begins with Alexander Csoma de Körös (1784 – 1842), the first in the West to mention mysterious Buddhist realm known as Shambhala, which he regarded as the origin of the Turkish people, and which he situated in the Altai mountains and Xinjiang.

Csoma de Körös’s mention of Shambhala became the basis of the mystical speculations offered by H. P. Blavatsky, which she regarded as the homeland of the Aryan race. Blavatsky founded the Theosophical Society, and came to be regarded as an oracle of Freemasonry and the godmother of the occult. Blavatsky became largely responsible for initiating the popularity of Buddhism as a font of the Ancient Wisdom. However, contrary to popular perceptions, Tibetan Buddhism is a strange amalgam of Buddhist ideas, along with Hindu Tantra and Central Asian shamanism, it was for this reason that Blavatsky regarded it as the true preservation of the traditions of magic.

 

Abdul Qadir al Jazairi

Benjamin Disraeli

Abdul Qadir al Jazairi

The myth of Sufism as the origin of Freemasonry developed through the influence of Abdul Qadir al Jazairi (1808 – 1883), an Algerian national hero who led a struggle against the French invasion of their country in the mid-nineteenth century. Abdul Qadir was ultimately forced to surrender, and eventually settled in Damacus, Syria, under a generous pension from the French.

In 1860, he attained international fame when he and his personal guard saved large numbers of Christians who had come under attack by the local Druze population. As reward, the French government bestowed on him the Grand Cross of the Légion d’honneur and he was also honored by Abraham Lincoln. As well, the town of Elkaker of Iowa was named after him.

Abdul Qadir had been initiated into the Naqshbandi, into the Qadiriyya by his own father, and into the Darqawi branch of the Shadhili Sufi order, by the student of its founder, al Arabi ad-Darqawi. The Shadhili was branched to the Akbariyya chain, going back to the “Shaykh Al-Akbar” (Greatest Sheikh), referring to Arab mystic, Ibn Arabi (1165 – 1240). However, Ibn Arabi was condemned by the vast majority of orthodox Muslim scholars as a heretic. The reason Ibn Arabi served the purposes of these Sufi Masons was for his belief in the doctrine of a “Universal Brotherhood,” which was the core of the mission of Freemasonry and Theosophy, and the basis of their pretext of establishing a one-world religion.

Abdul Qadir was also friends with Jane Digby and Sir Richard Burton, the famous British explorer, spy and fellow Freemason, who had been made consul in Damascus in 1869. Digby, or Lady Ellenborough (1807-1881), was an English aristocrat who lived a scandalous life of romantic adventures, having had four husbands and many lovers. Burton and Digby were also close friends of Wilfred Scawen Blunt and his wife Lady Anne, a grand-daughter of poet Lord Byron. Blunt was the handler of British agent Jamal ud Din al Afghani and his disciple, Mohammed Abduh, the founders of the fundamentalist tradition of Islam known as Salafism, from which emerged the Muslim Brotherhood.[1]

Rene Guenon

Réne Guénon

Burton was also an avid occultist, and like Abdul Qadir, a member of the Qadiriyya Sufi order, because “Sufism,” he claimed, is “the Eastern parent of Freemasonry.”[2] Burton was also a member of the Theosophical Society of Blavatsky, who visited him in Damascus. According to historian K. Paul Johnson, Afghani was one of Blavatsky’s “Ascended Masters,” from whom she learned her central doctrines. Afghani was the reputed head of a mysterious order known as the Hermetic Brotherhood of Luxor (or Light), which exercised a profound influence over the occult societies of the period, culminating in the Ordo Templi Orientis (OTO) of the scandalous Aleister Crowley.

Most important to the transmission of Sufism to the West was Réne Guénon, a one-time member of the Hermetic Brotherhood of Light. Guénon founded the occult school of Traditionalism, which suggests that all exoteric religions share a single underlying occult tradition. Therefore, according to Guénon, one could choose any religion as one’s outward belief, and so he chose Islam.

Guénon’s initiation was effected by Swedish convert to Islam Ivan Aguéli, who was also interested in Kabbalah, and performed under the authority of the friend of Abdul Qadir al Jazairi, Sheikh Abder Rahman Illaysh al Kabir, a Freemason and head of the Maliki Madhhab at Al Azhar University. As a Freemason, al Kabir also aimed to demonstrate the relationship between the symbols of Freemasonry and Islam.[3]

 

George Gurdjieff

George I. Gurdjieff

George I. Gurdjieff

Also promoting the origin of shamanism as the source of ancient wisdom was the chief propagandist for the popularization of Sufism within the New Age, George Gurdjieff (1866 – 1949), a charismatic hypnotist, carpet trader and spy of Armenian origin. Gurdjieff’s teaching claimed that human beings were helplessly caught in a “waking sleep” unable to fully perceive reality, but that it is possible for them to transcend to a higher state of consciousness and achieve their full human potential. He developed a method for doing so called “The Work” or “the Method.” Because his method for awakening one’s consciousness was different from that of the fakir, monk or yogi, his discipline is also called the “Fourth Way.” As Gurdjieff explained, “The way of the development of hidden possibilities is a way against nature and against God.”[4]

Gurdjieff’s deceptive and tyrannical ways led to his reputation as a “rascal guru.” He was widely referred to as a black magician, and Rasputin was so fearful of him that he was quoted to have said, “I had been especially careful not to look at Gurdjieff and not to allow him to look into my eyes...”[5] He was criticized by many of his former students as being slovenly, gluttonous and was notorious for seducing his female students and fathering several illegitimate children. P. D. Ouspensky, his leading student, finally broke with him, claiming that he was “a very extraordinary man,” but that it was “dangerous to be near him.”[6] Another of his famous student, J. G. Bennett, warned that Gurdjieff “is far more of an enigma than you can imagine. I am certain that he is deeply good, and that he is working for the good of mankind. But his methods are often incomprehensible.”[7]

Karl Haushofer & Rudolf Hess

Karl Haushofer & Rudolf Hess

Louis Pauwels, a former student of Gurdjieff, in his book Monsieur Gurdjieff, asserts that one of the “Searchers After Truth” that Gurdjieff speaks of in his book Meetings with Remarkable Men was Karl Haushofer, "the magician, the secret master," who through his student Rudolf Hess, influenced the development of Adolf Hitler's geopolitical strategies. Haushofer was also a leading member of the Thule Society, from which evolved the Nazi Party, and founded by Baron Rudolf von Sebottendorf, who had studied Kabbalah in Turkey under Bektashi Sufis who were also Freemasons. Haushofer was apparently influenced by Gurdjieff's teaching that men are asleep and waiting for a strong leader to force them to wake up and become supermen. Haushofer was supposed to have been with Gurdjieff in Tibet, and it was then that Gurdjieff supposedly advised Haushofer to adopt the symbol of the swastika.[8]

There has also often been the suggestion that Gurdjieff and Joseph Dzhugashvili, later known as Stalin, met as young students while attending the same seminary in Tiflis in the Caucasus. Gurdjieff’s family records contain information that Stalin lived in his family’s house for a while.[9] There are also suggestions that Stalin belonged to an occult "eastern brotherhood," which consisted of Gurdjieff and his followers.[10]

Gurdjieff’s thought is an amalgam of Theosophy, Neopythagoreanism, Rosicrucianism and alchemy. According to James Webb, author of The Harmonious Circle: The Anatomy of a Myth, the first comprehensive book on Gurdjieff and his movement, Blavatsky’s Theosophy was his single most important source. Additionally, as K. Paul Johnson notes, “a comparison of the teachings of Blavatsky and Gurdjieff leads to the conclusion that both are equally indebted to another source, Ismaili Shi’ism.”[11] According to Johnson, Blavatsky’s likely source for this Ismaili influence would have been Jamal ud Din al Afghani, who was simultaneously the Grand Master of Freemasonry in Egypt, as well as founder of fundamentalist reform group, known as Salafism.

Having studied with the Bektashi Sufis, Gurdjieff also adopted the belief in shamanism as the source of the Sufi tradition. Gurdjieff’s Fourth Way teachings mentioned a “Universal Brotherhood” and also a mysterious group of monks called the Sarmoung (also: Sarman, Sarmouni). Both groups were described as in possession of advanced knowledge and powers, and as being open to suitable candidates from all creeds. In the account of Gurdjieff’s wanderings, Meetings with Remarkable Men, he describes encounters in many parts of the world, including Central Asia, Egypt and Rome. Gurdjieff then ventures to Central Asia to search out and locate the mysterious Sarmoung Brotherhood. The chief monastery of the society was said to be located somewhere in the heart of Asia, about twelve days’ journey by horse and donkey from Bukhara in Uzbekistan.

J. G. Bennett

J. G. Bennett

From the Sarmoung, Gurdjieff learns the sacred dances, much like those of the Whirling Dervishes, which constitute an integral part of his “the work.” According to Gurdjieff’s leading student J. G. Bennett, who was head of British Military Intelligence in Istanbul and his friend Idries Shah, the popular author of Sufism, Gurdjieff’s “Fourth Way” originated with the Khwajagan, a chain of Naqshbandi Sufi Masters from the tenth to the sixteenth century influenced by Central Asian shamanism. According to Bennett, the Sufis are the descendants and spiritual heirs of the old master magicians of Altai, where Central Asia has been their heartland for forty thousand years or more.

As Bennett relates, the Sarmoun became active in the rise of Zoroastrianism, and he connects the influence of the Magi to the Essenes.[12] Gurdjieff believed that the true teachings of Jesus Christ were corrupted by the Christian Church, but that a small group of initiates called the “Brotherhood of the Essenes” were able to secretly preserve them. Likewise, Gurdjieff believed that Islam as well had deviated from the original teachings of the Prophet Mohammed. Gurdjieff believed that the esoteric teachings of Islam were in Bokhara, in Central Asia, which Bennett believes was associated with the Naqshbandi Sufis who had preserved the true teachings of Islam, and which represented a synthesis of the inner meaning of all religions.

In 1953, Bennett had undertaken a long journey to the Middle East, which included a mysterious visit to Abdullah Faizi ad Daghestani (1891-1973), Shaykh of the Naqshbandi Haqqani Sufi order, in Damascus.[13] Ad Daghestani initiated Gurdjieff and allowed him through a dream to “ascend to the knowledge of the power of the nine points,” which became the basis of his Enneagram.[14] The enneagram is a nine-pointed figure usually inscribed within a circle. Gurdjieff is quoted by Ouspensky as claiming that it was an ancient secret and was now being partly revealed for the first time, though hints of the symbol could be found in esoteric literature. It has been proposed that it may derive from the Kabbalistic Tree of Life, as used in Renaissance Hermeticism, which used an enneagram of three interlocking triangles, also called a nonagram or a nine-pointed figure used by the Christian medieval philosopher Raymond Lull.[15]

 

MK-Ultra

Aldous Huxley

Aldous Huxley

Through the influence of the Romanian Traditionalist historian, Mircea Eliade, brought forward the idea that its mystical feats of the shamans of Central Asian were achieved through the use of drugs, often referred to as “entheogens.” In 1954, Aldous Huxley, who studied Eliade, wrote the The Doors of Perception, which also reflected the ideas of Gurdjieff, and claimed that hallucinogenic drugs “expand consciousness.” Like many of the leading LSD evangelists of the CIA’s MK-Ultra program, including Huxley, Gerald Heard and Alan Watts, Timothy Leary was strongly influenced by Gurdjieff.

Gurdjieff believed that the ascetic practices of monks, fakirs and yogis resulted in the production of psychological substances that produced their religious or mystical experiences. Instead of the torturous practices of these mystics, Gurdjieff proposed that the man who knows the Fourth Way “simply prepares and swallows a little pill which contains all the substances he wants. And in this way, without loss of time, he obtains the required result.”[16] Leary later remarked about receiving a copy of the Fourth Secret Teaching of Gurdjieff:

 

For the past twenty years, we Gurdjieff fans had been titillated by rumors of this Fourth Book, which supposedly listed secret techniques and practical methods for attaining the whimsical, post-terrestrial levels obviously inhabited by the jolly Sufi Master [Gurdjieff]. We had always assumed, naturally, that the secret methods involved drugs. So it was a matter of amused satisfaction to read in this newly issued text that not only were brain-activating drugs the keys to Gurdjieff's wonderful, whirling wisdom, but also that the reason for keeping the alkaloids secret was to avoid exactly the penal incarceration which I was enjoying when the following essay was penned."[17]

 

Timothy Leary

Timothy Leary

Leary apparently first became interested in psychedelics when he read a 1957 article by Gordon Wasson published in Life magazine titled “Seeking the Magic Mushroom,” which brought knowledge of the existence of psychoactive mushrooms to a wide audience for the first time. Wasson, who was a vice president of JP Morgan and served as a chairman to the CFR, and had close ties to CIA chief Allen Dulles. Wasson and Henry Luce—Skull and Bones member and creator of Life magazine—were also long time members of the Century Club, a CIA front, along with John Foster Dulles, Walter Lippmann, and George Kennan.[18] Time-Life was created by Henry P. Davison Jr, also a member of Skull and Bones, who was Wasson's boss at J. P. Morgan.

Wasson was associated with at least six people suspected of being involved in the JFK assassination, including C. D. Jackson and Henry Luce. Wasson’s name was found in the address book that was retrieved from the briefcase of George de Mohrenschildt, a friend of Lee Harvey Oswald, after his death. The address book also contained an entry for “Bush, George H. W. (Poppy).” Although de Mohrenschildt denied any Nazi sympathies, his application to join the OSS during World War II was rejected, because, according to a memo by former CIA director Richard Helms he was alleged to be a Nazi spy. In addition to the Bush family, de Mohrenschildt was also acquainted with the Bouvier family, including Jacqueline Bouvier Kennedy.

Gordon Wasson

Gordon Wasson

Robert Graves

Robert Graves

Wasson is considered the founder of Ethnomycology, the study of psychoactive mushrooms used for spiritual purposes, inspiring later researchers such as Terence McKenna and John Allegro. Wasson wrote in Leary’s The Psychedelic Review that the magic mushroom “permits you to see more clearly than our perishing eye can see, vistas beyond the horizons of life, to travel backwards and forwards in time, to enter other planes of existence, even to know God.”[19] In 1967 Wasson would publish Soma: Divine Mushroom of Immortality, which proposed that the ancient Vedic intoxicant Soma was the magic mushroom. Wasson would later discuss the Eleusinian Mysteries, in The Road to Eleusis: Unveiling the Secret of the Mysteries, co-authored with Albert Hofmann, the Swiss scientist who discovered LSD, who proposed that the special potion “kykeon,” used in the ceremony, contained psychoactive substances from the fungus Ergot, from which LSD was developed.

Wasson was also close friends with Robert Graves, the author of The White Goddess, a key book for modern Pagans and Wiccans, in which he proposes the existence of a European deity, inspired and represented by the phases of the moon, and which is the origin of the goddesses of various European and pagan mythologies.

Graves also wrote the introduction to Idries Shah’s The Sufis. As the secretary to Gerald Gardner, one of the key representatives of Wicca, whose rituals he developed with Aleister Crowley, Shah was responsible for popularizing that European witchcraft, as well as the occult tradition in general, was derived from Sufism.

Towards the end of the 1950s, Shah established contact with Wiccan circles in London and served as a secretary and companion to Gerald Gardner, the founder of Wicca, whose rituals he formulated with Aleister Crowley. Shortly before his death, Crowley elevated Gardner to the VII° of the OTO, and issued a charter decreeing that Gardner could perform its preliminary initiation rituals.[20] After Crowley’s death in 1947, Gardner was regarded as the chief representative of the OTO in Europe.

idries Shah

Idries Shah

Gerald Gardner

Gerald Gardner

Shah met Graves in 1961, and later wrote to him that he was researching ecstatic religions, and that he had been “attending… experiments conducted by the witches in Britain, into mushroom-eating and so on.” Shah also told Graves that he was “intensely preoccupied at the moment with the carrying forward of ecstatic and intuitive knowledge.”[21] Graves encouraged Shah to publish an authoritative book on Sufism for a Western audiences, which became The Sufis.

Graves’ introduction described Shah as being “in the senior male line of descent from the prophet Mohammed” and as having inherited “secret mysteries from the Caliphs, his ancestors. He is, in fact, a Grand Sheikh of the Sufi Tariqa…” Graves confessed, however, that this was “misleading: he is one of us, not a Moslem personage.”[22]

In June 1962, a couple of years prior to the publication of The Sufis, Shah had also established contact with members of the movement that had formed around the mystical teachings of Gurdjieff and Ouspensky. He was eventually introduced to J. G. Bennett, who became convinced that Shah “had a very important mission in the West that we ought to help him to accomplish.”[23] Shah gave Bennett a “Declaration of the People of the Tradition.” Shah declared that the Guardians belonged to an “invisible hierarchy” that had chosen him to transmit “a secret, hidden, special, superior form of knowledge.” It convinced Bennett that Shah was a genuine emissary of Gurdjieff’s “Sarmoung Monastery.”

In The Commanding Self, Idries Shah, contends that the Enneagram is of Sufi origin, and that it has also been long known in coded form as an octagram, two superimposed squares with the space in the middle representing the ninth point. In 1960, Shah founded Octagon Press, which was named after the octagram. One of its first titles was a biography titled Gerald Gardner, Witch, which Shah wrote under the pen name of Jack L. Bracelin.

Shah was also a member of the Club of Rome, a project initiated by the Rockefeller family at their estate at Bellagio, Italy.[24] The founders of the Club of Rome were all senior officials of NATO. These included Aurelio Peccei, the chairman of Fiat who was also chairman of the Economic Committee of the Atlantic Institute, and Alexander King, the co-founder, who was Director General of Scientific Affairs of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD).

Seyyed Hossein Nasr

Seyyed Hossein Nasr

Ian Dallas (aka Abdul Qadir al Murabit)

Ian Dallas (aka Abdul Qadir al Murabit)

In 1965, Shah founded SUFI (Society for Understanding Fundamental Ideas), and dubbed himself Great-Sheikh, not only of the Naqshbandi, but of all Sufi orders. Several presentations were given by scientists like Alexander King to the Institute for Cultural Research (ICR), which was originally founded by Shah in 1965 as the Society for Understanding Fundamental Ideas (SUFI).[25] Other visitors, pupils, and would-be pupils included the poet Ted Hughes, novelists Alan Sillitoe and Doris Lessing, zoologist Desmond Morris, and psychologist Robert Ornstein. Over the following years, Shah established Octagon Press as a means of distributing reprints of translations of Sufi classics. Several of Shah’s books, Mulla Nasrudin, considered a folkloric part of Muslim cultures, were presented as Sufi parables, and which were discussed the Rand Corporation.[26]

At a November 1977 Lisbon conference sponsored by the Interreligious Peace Colloquium, Club of Rome founder Aurelio Peccei, the chairman of Fiat, conspired with several leading members of the Muslim Brotherhood, particularly with Seyyed Hossein Nasr of Teheran University, who was highly active during the Iranian revolution of 1979.[27] Nasr is a Perennialist in the school of Guénon’s Traditionalism. Nasr was initiated into the Darqawi Shadhili by Ahmad al-Alawi (1869-1934), who had been recommended to him by Guénon.

Nasr was a student of Guénon’s leading disciple Frithjof Schuon who established the Maryamiyya branch of the Shadhili in Europe and North America. Some of Schuon’s most eminent students include supposed converts to Islam, Titus Burckhardt and Martin Lings, best known as the author of a very popular and positively reviewed biography of Muhammad, first published in 1983. But according to Andrew Rawlinson, in Book of Enlightened Masters, Schuon was not as a pious Sufi but as a charlatan.

Another known initiate of the Darqawi Shadhili descended from Ahmad Al-Alawi is a Scottish convert to Islam named Ian Dallas, a.k.a. Sheikh Abdalqadir al-Murabit. Dallas, who founded the Murabitun movement, celebrates Hitler as a “great genius and great vision,” praises Wagner as the “most spiritual of men among men in a age of darkness,” and regards the black stone of the Kabbah in Mecca as the Holy Grail. In 1990, he held a symposium in honor of the occultist Ernst Junger, one of the fathers of Nazi ideology, and which ended with a Masonic ceremonial. Also in attendance was Albert Hofmann, the scientist who discovered LSD, associated with the CIA’s MK-Ultra program.[28]

 

Esalen Institute

Esalen Institute

Nude therapy at Esalen

Gurdjieff and Shah were important inspirations behind the hokey “spiritual” practices endorsed by the Tavistock-affiliated Esalen Institute which, according to Wouter Hanegraaff, in New Age Religion and Western Culture: Esotericism in the Mirror of Secular Thought, in addition of the Hippies, had been the second major influence of the 60s counterculture and the rise of the New Age movement.[29]  Formed at Oxford University, in 1920 by the Round Table’s Royal Institute for International Affairs (RIIA), the sister organization to the Council on Foreign Relations, the Tavistock Clinic became the Psychiatric Division of the British Army during World War II. A successor organization, the Tavistock Institute of Human Relations, was then founded in 1946 under a grant from the Rockefeller Foundation.

According to a former British Intelligence agent John Coleman, Tavistock became known as the focal point in Britain for psychoanalysis and the psychodynamic theories of Sigmund Freud and his followers. Its clients are chiefly public sector organizations, including the European Union, several British government departments, and some private clients. Its network now extends from the University of Sussex to the US through the Stanford Research Institute (SRI), Esalen Institute, MIT, Hudson Institute, Brookings Institution, Aspen Institute, Heritage Foundation, the Center of Strategic and International Studies at Georgetown, US Air Force Intelligence, and the RAND Corporation.

And, according to BBC documentary filmmaker Adam Curtis, in The Century of the Self, “The ideas and the techniques that were taught there in the 1970s have fundamentally transformed both society and politics as much, or possibly even more, than any right-wing free market theories.” As Adam Curtis explains:

 

[Esalen] gathered together a group of radical psychoanalysts and psychotherapists and encouraged them to give classes in their techniques. What united them was the belief that modern society repressed individuals inner feelings. Because of this the individuals led narrow, desiccated lives and their true feelings were bent and warped.

Esalen taught people how to break out of this prison, how to let their inner feelings out and so become liberated beings. It was a wonderful dream—and thousands of people who had turned away from radical politics in the 1960s came to learn how to change society by changing themselves.[30]

 

Claudio Naranjo

Claudio Naranjo

Oscar Ichazo

Oscar Ichazo

Esalen’s goal was to assist in a coming transformation by exploring work in the humanities and sciences, in order to fully realize what Aldous Huxley had called the “human potentialities.” Esalen thus represented a fruition of The Human Potential Movement (HPM), whose founding has often been attributed to Gurdjieff, and which arose in the 1960s around the concept of cultivating the extraordinary potential that its advocates believed to lie largely untapped in all people.

Idries Shah’s student, Claudio Naranjo along with Oscar Ichazo, were important figures in the Human Potential Movement, and developed the Enneagram of Gurdjieff into a pseudo-psychological personality profile system. Chilean psychiatrist Naranjo, belonged to the inner circle at Esalen, where he became one of the three successors to Fritz Perls, the founder of Gestalt Therapy.

Naranjo was also a member of the Tavistock-affiliated US Club of Rome, and in 1969 he was sought out as a consultant for the Education Policy Research Center, created by Willis Harman at Stanford Research Institute (SRI). Naranjo is regarded as one of the pioneers of the Human Potential Movement, for integrating psychotherapy and the spiritual traditions through the introduction of Gurdjieff’s  “Fourth Way” teachings.[31]

Naranjo was also a close friend of Carlos Castaneda, who is famous for having written a series of books that describe his alleged training in shamanism and the use of psychoactive drugs like peyote, under the tutelage of a Yaqui “Man of Knowledge” named Don Juan. According to Kripal, what Claudio Naranjo became known for was a creative synthesis of Asian meditation and western psychotherapy. Though his ideas were developed from Tantric Buddhism, he interpreted them in terms of Shamanism, and derived from what he called his “tantric journey” which involved a Kundalini experience, which he compared to both being possessed by a serpent and an alchemical process. As Kripal explains:

 

The “inner serpent” of kundalini yoga is simply a South Asian construction of a universal neurobiology; it is “no other than our more archaic (reptilian) brain-mind.” The serpent power “is ‘us’-i.e., the integrity of our central nervous system when cleansed of karmic interference,” the human body-mind restored to its own native spontaneity.

Put a bit differently, Naranjo’s “one quest” is a religion of no religion that has come to realize how “instinct” is really a kind of “organismic wisdom” and how libido is more deeply understood as a kind of divine Eros that can progressively mutate both spirit and flesh once it is truly freed from the ego.[32]

 

When Naranjo became disillusioned with Gurdjieff, he turned to Sufism and became a student of Idries Shah. Naranjo co-wrote a book entitled On The Psychology of Meditation (1971), with Stanford University psychologist professor Robert Ornstein. Both were associated with the University of California, where Ornstein was a research psychologist at the Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute. Ornstein, along with fellow psychologist Charles Tart and eminent writers such as Poet Laureate Ted Hughes and Nobel-Prize-winning novelist Doris Lessing, was profoundly influenced by Shah. Realizing that Ornstein could be an ideal partner in propagating his teachings, adapting them into the language of psychotherapy, Shah made him his deputy (Khalifa) in the United States.

Ornstein was also president and founder of the Institute for the Study of Human Knowledge (ISHK), established in 1969, with the aim of publishing books on ancient and new ways of thinking for American readers, and become the sole American distributor of Shah’s works of published by Octagon Press. Ornstein’s The Psychology of Consciousness (1972) was enthusiastically received by the academic psychology community, as it coincided with new interests in the field, such as biofeedback and other techniques to achieve shifts in mood and awareness.[33]

Oscar Ichazo, whose influence at Esalen is legendary, was heavily involved in psychedelic drugs and shamanism, and according to John C Lilly, who had been through the first levels of Ichazo’s Arica training, Ichazo claimed to have “received instructions from a higher entity called Metatron” and that his group “was guided by an interior master,” the “Green Qutb.”[34] Lilly, a friend to Timothy Leary and Allen Ginsberg, is known for his work on dolphin-human communication, as well as his experiments using hallucinogens while floating in isolation tanks. Lilly apparently gave dolphins LSD and told a story of one dolphin who seduced a man into having sex with her in a holding tank.[35] The 1980 movie Altered States, starting William Hurt, is partly based on his life.

Naranjo, who studied with Oscar Ichazo in Chile, passed on the Enneagram teachings to Jesuit Bob Ochs, who then brought it into Roman Catholic circles at Esalen, where Naranjo taught. However, the Christian tradition derived from Gurdjieff was one that rejected the belief in Jesus as a historical person, and instead insisted that religious experiences were derived from psychoactive substances.

 

The Naqshbandi Sufis

When Bennett, visited Sheikh ad Daghestani in Damascus in 1953, he gave Bennett an enigmatic message relating to the coming to his home in the West of “a Messenger from God,” which Bennett interpreted to mean Bapak Muhammad Subuh, the Indonesian leader of cult named Subud. Bennett believed that the “The Reappearance of Christ” as the “Avatar of Synthesis” prophesied by Alice Bailey must refer to Subud, and Bennett and many followers of Gurdjieff were initiated into the cult. Shah’s first published mention of Subud appears in his book The Way of the Sufi, published in the mid 1960s, claiming that Subud is of Qadiriyya and Naqshbandi origin. Shah slowly separated from Subud and started to gather his own disciples.

Bapak Muhammad Subuh

Bapak Muhammad Subuh

When asked as to his cult’s purpose, Subuh himself had said: “What is the purpose of spreading Subud? Well, primarily… it concerns the work people have come to call the… United Nations.”[36] At the time of Subuh’s death in 1987, the chairman of the World Subud Council was Varindra Tarzie Vittachi. In 1973, he had been appointed director of the UN World Population Year, after which he became director of information on public affairs for the UN Population Fund (1974-79). From 1980, until his retirement, he was deputy executive director of UNICEF, the UN Children’s Fund.

Gurdjieff’s visit to ad Daghestani and his instruction in the mysteries of the Nine Points was reported by Sheikh Kabbani, Chairman of the Naqshbandi Haqqani Sufi Order of America, in The Naqshbandi Sufi Way: History and Guidebook of the Saints of the Golden Chain, the foreword to which was written by Seyyed Hossein Nasr. Sheikh Kabbani is the son-in-law and deputy of Sheikh Nazim al Haqqani, leader of the Naqshbandi-Haqqani Order, who had also been a student of Sheikh ad Daghestani, and who went to Britain where made contact with Bennett’s circle from whom he developed his first group of followers.[37]

Sheikh Nazim Haqqani

Sheikh Nazim Haqqani

Sheikh Kabani

Sheikh Kabbani

In 1991, Haqqani made the first of four nationwide tours of the US, in a number of venues, including churches, temples, universities, mosques and New Age centers. Reportedly, during these speeches and Dhikr gatherings thousands of individuals entered the fold of Islam through his efforts. Regrettably, these are not converts to Islam, but are attracted to a hippie-dippy version that is more about Sufism’s vague promises of “spirituality.” The key to Haqqani’s success is his openness to Muslims as well as non-Muslims, and his flexibility towards Islamic law. According to Haqqani, “One is not entitled to refute or object to any of the matters of his sheikh even if he contradicts the pure rules of Islam.”[38]

Haqqani’s liberalism was exemplified in his visit in 1999 to Glastonbury in England, where Joseph of Arimathea was to have concealed the Holy Grail, and which is now a center of alternative spirituality. Haqqani called on the people to aim for eternity without regard of their religion, and acknowledged the local legend that Jesus had visited the site. A Haqqani community subsequently established itself in the town, engaging in Dhikr meetings, which include musical performances, Whirling Dervishes and “Sufi meditation” workshops. Haqqani believes in the coming of the Mahdi is immanent, and gives his followers the impression that he is in spiritual contact with him.[39]

Dr. Gibril Haddad

Dr. Gibril Haddad

Ramadan al-Bouti

Ramadan al-Bouti

Among the vocal opponents of Wahhabism and Salafism today are important Sufis like Dr. Gibril Haddad and Muhammad Said Ramadan al-Bouti. Haddad, a well-known scholar and religious leader of Lebanese-American background who converted to Islam, was listed amongst the inaugural 500 most influential Muslims in the world. After also exploring Shadhili Sufism, Haddad became a disciple of Sheikh Nazim Al-Haqqani, leader of the Naqshbandi-Haqqani Order.

Haddad was also a former teacher on the traditional online Islamic institute Sunnipath, and is a major contributor to the website ESheikh.com, which gives traditional teachings on Islamic spirituality. Sheikh Kabbani supervises Sunnah.org, which touts itself as one of the top Islamic websites in the world. Also associated with Kabbani’s wing of Shaikh Haqqani’s Naqshbandi-Haqqani order is Stephen “Suleyman” Schwartz, Jewish convert to Islam and author who has been published in a variety of media, including The Wall Street Journal. Schwartz is also a vocal critic of the “Wahhabi lobby,” having written The Two Faces of Islam: The House of Sa’ud from Tradition to Terror, and a defense of Sufism titled The Other Islam: Sufism and the Road to Global Harmony.

Al-Bouti, a highly popular doctor of Islamic Law from the University of Damascus and a noted critic of Salafism, is listed among the Top 50 of the 500 most influential Muslims in the world. Al-Bouti is also affiliated to the Naqshbandi branch in Syria, the only Sufi organization in the country to be allowed freedom of action by the Asad regime, with whom it is closely associated. This is despite the fact that the Asad family are members of the Alawi sect. Sheikh al-Bouti is the leading Islamic scholar in Syria. An active opponent of the Salafis, al-Bouti is the author of Abandoning the Maddhabs is the Most Dangerous Bid’ah Threatering the Islamic Shari’ah.

Also important to note that Nuh Ha Mim Keller features in this story. Keller belongs to the Darqawi Shadhili tradition, having been initiated by Al Shaghouri, a student of Ahmed al-Alawi, who was a friend of René Guénon, which links him indirectly to Schuon, Seyyed Hosein Nasr.

Although Keller openly denounces Guénon and Schuon, here merely represents a different branch of Traditionalism, having adopted its tradition of al Akbariyya, through the influence of Abdul Qadir al Jazairi, whom he regularly praises. And Keller has repeatedly attempted to justify Sufism as a legitimate science of Islam by referring to Ibn Khaldun, who apparently condoned it, but he fails to mention that Ibn Khaldun heavily chastised much of Sufi tradition as “Biddah” (heretical innovations) and names Ibn Arabi among the chief innovators. Ibn Khaldun also wrote a Fatwa declaring that Ibn Arabi’s books should be burned. [40]

Under the leadership of Ahmad Kuftaro (1915-2004), Grand Mufti of Syria, the Naqshbandi branch in Syria has been closely associated with the Muslim Brotherhood. Kuftaro was on good terms with Shaykh Haqqani, and in particular his deputy Kabbani, who sends some of his key students to him.[41] Kuftaro has been long engaged in interfaith dialogue, and upholds the belief that the three monotheistic religions stem from a common source, and are all different traditions of the one universal religion. Consequently, Kuftaro has been involved in an “Abrahamic dialogue,” advocated by many other leading Christians and Jews.

Reverend Sun Myung Moon and Ahmad Kuftaro

Reverend Sun Myung Moon and Ahmad Kuftaro

Kuftaro was one of the editorial advisors alongside an impressive collection of representatives from all kinds of religions of A World Scripture, that “gathers passages from the scriptures of the various religious traditions around certain topics,” first conceived by Reverend Sun Myung Moon. He also participated in the Assisi interfaith service for peace led by pope John Paul II in 1986.  He has gone as far as praying the Hail Mary with the Cardinal of Baltimore, Cardinal Keeler, who was the President of the National Conference of Catholic Bishops.[42]

In 2000, the UN organized the Millennium World Peace Summit consisting of more than a thousand religious leaders from the world’s religions, funded largely by private foundations such as Ted Turner’s Better World Fund and the Templeton, Carnegie and Rockefeller Brothers foundations. In addition to Kuftaro, the representatives included Francis Cardinal Arinze, president of the Vatican’s council for inter-religious dialogue; Konrad Raiser, secretary-general of the World Council of Churches; Rabbi Israel Meir Lau, the chief rabbi of Israel; Sheikh Abdullah Salaih Al-Obaid of the Muslim World League of Saudi Arabia.

The involvement of the supporters of the most fanatical fringes of Islam in the UN’s interfaith discussions betrays the true nature of their mission. Like Jamal ud Din al Afghani before them, they merely use the language of Islamic fundamentalism to assist their co-conspirators in the West in undermining Islam from within, towards its eventual replacement with a one-world New Age religion. The historical basis of this nefarious cooperation dates back to the relationship between the Templars and the Assassins who, though one being ostensibly Christian and the other outwardly Muslim, both shared not only an identical doctrine, that of the Kabbalah, but also a mendacious modus operandi which recognized the value of employing the guise of religion for manipulating the masses.

 



[2] F. Hitchman, Burton, Vol. I, p. 286.

[3]Abder-Rahman Elîsh El-Kebîr,” Wikipedia, French edition.

[4] P. D. Ouspensky, In Search of the Miraculous: Fragments of an Unknown Teaching, (Harcourt, 1949). p. 47.

[5] Colin Wilson, Rasputin and the Fall of the Romanovs, (Farrar Straus & Co., 1964), p. 103.

[6] John G. Bennett Witness: The Autobiography of John G. Bennett (Tucson: Omen Press, 1974), p. 126.

[7] Ibid., p. 244.

[8] Gary Lachman, Politics and the Occult; James Webb, The Harmonious Circle (Thames and Hudson: London, 1980).

[9] Luba Gurdjieff, A Memoir with Recipes (Berkely, CA: Ten Spead Press, 1993, p. 3; cited in Paul Beekman Taylor, Gurdjieff and Orage: Brothers in Elysium, (Weiser, 2001), p. x.

[10] Margarita Troitsyna, “Joseph Stalin's occult knowledge and experiments,” Pravda (June 23, 2011)

[11] K. Paul Johnson, Initiates of Theosophical Masters, (Albany: State University of New York Press, 1995) p. 141.

[12] Victoria Lepage, "G.I. Gurdjieff & the Hidden History of the Sufis,” New Dawn (March 1, 2008).

[13]  “A New World Sufi Order?Islamic Party of Britain (Autumn 1993)

[14] Shaykh Muhammad Hisham Kabbani, The Naqshbandi Sufi Way: History and Guidebook of the Saints of the Golden Chain, (KAZI, 1995).

[15] James Webb, The Harmonious Circle: The Lives and Work of G.I. Gurdjieff, P.D. Ouspensky, and Their Followers, (New York and London: Putnam USA, and Thames and Hudson, 2001).

[16] Peter Ouspensky, In Search of the Miraculous (Harcourt, 1949) p. 50.

[17] Tim Leary, Changing my mind among others, (Prentice-Hall, 1982) p. 192-3.

[18] Jan Irwin, “The Secret History of Magic Mushrooms,” Gnosis Media.

[19] R. Gordon Wasson, “The Hallucinogenic Fungi of Mexico,” The Psychedelic Review, vol. 1, no. 1, (June 1963), p. 30.

[21]  Paul O'Prey, Between Moon and Moon – Selected Letters of Robert Graves 1946–1972, (Hutchinson, 1984), pp. 213–215.

[22]  Paul O'Prey, Between Moon and Moon – Selected Letters of Robert Graves 1946–1972, (Hutchinson, 1984), pp. 213–215.

[23] John G. Bennett, Witness: The autobiography of John G. Bennett. (Tucson: Omen Press, 1974), pp. 355–363.

[24] See Robert Dreyfuss, Hostage to Khomeini.

[25] Elizabeth Hall, “At Home in East and West: A Sketch of Idries Shah,” Psychology Today 9 (2): 56 (July 1975).

[26] Idries Shah (Presenter), “One Pair of eyes: Dreamwalkers,” BBC Television, (19 Dec 1970).

[27] Dreyfuss, Hostage to Khomeini, [excerpt: http://www.hoveyda.org/aspen77.html]

[28] Othman Abu-Sahnun the Italian, “The Murabituns & Free Masonry,” Murabitun Files.

[29] Wouter J. Hanegraaff, New Age Religion and Western Culture: Esotericism in the Mirror of Secular Thought, (Boston, Massachusetts, US: Brill Academic Publishers, 1996), pp. 38–39.

[30] Adam Curtis, “The Curse of Tina Part Two: Learning to Hug.” BBC Blogs: Adam Curtis: The Medium and the Message. (October 4, 2011).

[31]Claudio Naranjo, M.D..,” Blue Dolphin Publishing.

[33] David Westerlund (ed.), Sufism in Europe and North America. (New York, NY: RoutledgeCurzon, 2004), p. 53.

[34] John C. Lilly & Joseph E. Hart, “The Arica Training,” Transpersonal psychologies, edited by Charles T Tart (Routledge, 1975).

[35] Kripal, Esalen, p. 178.

[36]  “A New World Sufi Order?” Islamic Party of Britain (Autumn 1993)

[37] Umar Ibrahim Vadillo, The Esoteric Deviation in Islam, (Cape Town South Africa: Madinah Press, 2003), p. 447.

[39] Itzchak Weismann, TThe Naqshbandiyya: Orthodoxy and Activism in a Worldwide Sufi Tradition, (London: Routledge, 2007) p. 170.

[40] Muqaddimah Q I 201-202, and M. al-Tanji’s edition of the Shifa’ al-Sa’il fi Tahdhib al-Masa’il, (Istanbul, 1958), pp. 110-11 quoted from James W. Morris, "An Arab ‘Machiavelli’.”

[41] Umar Ibrahim Vadillo, The Esoteric Deviation in Islam, (Cape Town South Africa: Madinah Press, 2003) p. 632.

[42] Pacific Church News Vol. 153 no. 3, June/July 1997.

 

Comments

New age

im confused about this movement i thought they were peaceful and liberal, what the difference between them and conservatives? What does occult mean?

New age is a spiritual

New age is a spiritual movement that started or was brought in the 1960's by the Freemasons. The New Age Spirituality is the Envisioned religion for the future. Here is a great article describing the New Age and its key beliefs. http://endalltyranny.wordpress.com/2013/09/21/the-new-world-religion-for...

Im still struggling wit the

Im still struggling wit the notion the london nased intel services were that together and so far sighted as to set up Wahabism as a trojaan horse. The auther William Engdahls concept of weaponising Islam into destroying itself seems apposite but thats used by him to describe more current events setting Sunni and Shia ( etc etc) against each other.

So Im needing some more evidence re the British involvement

Plus the hippies in a field thing for post new agers is a sharp point. As a student of Sufism I read Murshid SAM (Sufi Ahmed Murad Chisti as was Samuel L Lewis was awarded by some airforce intel an important medal after WW2 for esoteric services rumoured to be assisting death camp victims - which would be a worthy enough but I have to question wether the USAF was likely to award a medal for that ... or something else.

However SAM wrote a book in which he called himself 'the new age in person' and thats the title of the book I think. He also brought a lot of attention to the Sufi message of Inayat Khan - whose daughter Noor Inayat Khan was killed in a concentration camp for being a brave unarmed spy

Are all these strands of Sufism false for you as well

- I understand Sufis consider the Quran mentions people already exisiting for who the message isnt so needful

Is the phrase I recall 'people of purity' or such like - Sufis consider they are older than the Quran and Prophet Mohammed - how do these fit in with your views that it was a farsighted subtefuge against Islam if it does have a real claim to predate it?

The Abrahamic tradition meme you refer to was the last shred of inclusive peacemaking I could believe in re the insanity in the Holy Land - if you are saying its syncretism etc then I have no peg to hang my hopes on as Sufis seemed to be a 3rd way out of the Sunni Shia thing-

Any responses most welcome in regard to viable peacebuilding and general goodwill etc

British Intel

The details of the British creation of the Wahhabi sect are found in the Memoirs of Hempher.

Mir’at al Harramin, a Turkish work by Ayyub Sabri Pasha, written in 1888, made the same claim, stating that in Basra, Abdul Wahhab had come into contact with a British spy by the name of Hempher, who “inspired in him the tricks and lies that he had learned from the British Ministry of the Commonwealth.”

I don't know if we can say that the British planned the use of Wahhabism that far back. The British did create other groups as well, like the Sanussi Brotherhood, and also used many Sufi orders, like the Bektashi. But of all of them, the Wahhabis likely it proved to be most useful over the centuries.

Also read Robert Dreyfuss' Hostage to Khomeini [PDF], especially the chapters on the Muslim Brotherhood, as well as his most recent book, Devil's Game: How the US Helped Unleash Islamic Fundamentalism.

As for the Sufism, when they say they are older than the Quran and Mohammed, that is a dead give-away to their heretical leanings. The only tradition that precedes Islam is that of the recognized Prophets of the Bible and People of the Book. What Sufis are referring to in such cases is the occult, showing that their adherence to Islam is merely a cover.

BTWS

Just drifted in to your site and rather than mess about I have purchased BTWS.

Have spent many years searching Europe for the stories of Mithras, Bulls and other Gods - today trying to resolve the pressure points down the fault line of europe based around the burgundian core between Goths/visigoths and the Franks. I was looking at Scythians this afternoon and the connection with the warlike tribes of Benjamin and Dan.

At closer to 60 than I would like it is great fun to have your ideas substantiated (or refuted) even though someone else got to the answer before you. As you are aware its always about the research and thought; the journey too perhaps.

It may sound a bit naff (english expression for something between simple headed / poor taste or in this case a bit sycophantic) but I am genuinely excited at reading the book that will arrive from Amazon on 26th. I hope to be your first UK reviewer soon after.

Kind regards
Stephen

Scythians

Thanks Andrew. Hope you find the information in BTWS valuable. I've expanded some on the Scythians. Fascinating topic, as is the entire issue of the so-called Lost Tribes. Whether they existed or not, they were a very important theme throughout the occult tradition. Interesting to note that Scotland means land of the Scythians.

very interesting

very interesting article, it reminds me of how indian peninsula was converted to islam by sufi's who went among the unbelievers instead of open war.

i have been following the Esalen/Wasson/Mckenna etc angle as lately publicized by Jan Irvin of gnosticmedia. i had never thought that the new age would connect this strongly with Sufism.

i have been brought up on Sufi Music and Rumi etc and really liked their liberal universal way of seeing the world, and noticed that often they went against orthodox islam in their poetry.

to me when i still was a muslim it appealed to me and kept me longer in the fold of religion than i should have.

later when i started to really free my mind of brainwashing i also saw the paralells of Qawwaili/Sufi music and also church gatherings and techniques employed by Cults to hypnotize their followers and make them stop thinking critically.

Also a lot of Sheiks are just impostors and predatory types praying on the person who is deperate.

And the techniques they employ are placebo-effect or partly real Magic, -> talisman, writing verses from the quran blowing in faces, praying over food, ancestor worship, djinn/posession excorcism etc. Some use Hasjiesj

now i start to realize these are the same things used in different strains of Sjamanism.

it's all centered around changing one's mindstate through trance , and the popular Sufi musicians ( Sabri Bros, Nusrat fateh ali khan etc) have been touring the world and United states many times since the 70's .

I think after the new ager goes through the drugs-phase and doesnt find the Fix or illusion they are chasing after, th sufi path becomes the next thing as a more ''sobered up'' less toxic path.

But for me it is still brainwashing, altough i have nor found really destructive things in the teachings except :

that they think it is the highes ideal to merge with the beloved and rather die then then to live in this shadowworld.

it reminds me of the disturbed ascetism professed by the buddha, christian monks, fakirs , gandhi etc,
and the very negative view of this world we inhabit.

Why not try to live in this world the best you can instead of trying to flee from it in zikr and other trance-hypnotic trips without drugs ?

As my experience goes, the qawwali music does have a strong impact on the mind and fou feel elevation and lighter and quieter in the mind, but i nowadays rather use my mind and think critically about things because i'm interested in the world and do not wish to spend too much time wasting.

my opinion is : a religion is a big cult and a cult is a small religion. every religion started out as a conspiratorial cult of a few against the consensus of the time and place.
and after generations when it grows, people become more anchored because it integrates into culture like a mind-virus. and people do not see the negative aspects of the particular side of Plato's Cave they happen to live in.

Awareness

I think people are missing the point of Sufism.One should not lose oneself, but instead build awareness of themselves and the world around them.Gurdjieff's belief that people were asleep means they lacked awareness.

This awareness is hindered by internal chatter,the dialogue in a persons head that requires strong effort to control.

This awareness doesn't really jibe with losing oneself in drug use, etc.

dhikr

dhikr actually comes from the arabic root of ذكر
Some of the derived meanings from that root are:

to remember/commemorate/recollect, study in order to remember, remind, bear in mind, mindful, mention/tell/relate, magnify/praise, admonish/warn (e.g. dhikra is the 2nd declenation and it is stronger than dhikr), preach, extol, give status.
nobility/eminence/honour, fame, good report, cause of good reputation, means of exaltation.
Male/man/masculine (dhakar, dual - dhakarain, plural - dhukur).

You will note that the doublespeak version of that word ends up being like sex, drugs and music i.e. lose yourself and mind and even memory, concentration etc and be neglectful and carefree. That is the direct opposite of religion as per its etymology. Which according to Cicero was from relegere meaning re-read. And also the opposite of negligens ie religiens meaning careful.
But I learned that a certain group of scholars who believed in the idea that polytheism was the original belief, they pushed another claim of origin. And you can see that their belief was a bias against the original meaning and modern compared to Cicero.

Good points

I don't agree that religion is a cult, but you made a lot of other very good points. I entirely agree with what you say is the problem about the life-denying tendencies of asceticism. And mysticism tends to promote aspiring to achieve "other-worldly" experiences, instead of improving one's role in the world. And that is the fundamental difference between mysticism and orthodox tradition, as that, despite its heavy corruption by mysticism, was its original intent. It's all about social justice, and taking care of the here and now.

Here's a great quote my famous historian Ibn Khaldun, who explained that there were two types of Sufis, one was legitimate, and the other deviant. James Morris explains, Ibn Khaldun denounced the other-worldly aspirations of Sufism, and:

"...the much more and down-to-earth consequences of diverting substantial societal and human resources to the pointless, imaginary distractions and pastimes of such large groups of "simpletons," and the perhaps even more debilitating long-range consequences of their attempting to lead a moral and religious life somehow separate from what they allegedly viewed as the "corrupting" sphere of political and military power and authority." (An Arab “Machiavelli”?)

thanks for your reaction

Thank you for your well thought out reaction.

I think there is a time and place for some form of sjamanic practise , and psychedelic plants as they are grown in nature and are so compatible with our brainchemistry. i believe humanity has used the plants for a very long time predating civilization as we know it.

But caveat , it can have a detrimental effect on some people and some predators use these ´´otherworldly experiences ´´ especially in group settings to control other less experienced persons.
And that goes also for the sufi practises and thus Gurdjieff´s techniques.

I think it can be a beneficial tool if it is coupled with a mind wich is trained in critical thinking and has freed itself of irrational beliefs wich have been assimilated over a lifetime .

the problem i have with religion as my experience has been is that most of us are taught from a very young age on , when our mind is still in ´´copy-paste´´ mode, absorbing everything we get into our subconsciousness uncritically for most of us.

also if the core group of a child and the surrounding culture reinforces the internalized beliefs it becomes hard to ever develop real critical thinking capabilities in total freedom.

The mind gets blocked from certain thoughts so one can be trapped in a invisible caged perception of reality and not even know one is.

the selfinforced prison as one is it´s own warden and mindpolice and censor.

The problem I have with Orthodoxie is that it becomes dogmatic in it´s impositions on society.
I find it very suffocating as i am very curious to the nature of reality and keep an open mind and the privilige to entertain any idea without fear of punishment, and i upgrade my beliefs if i gain new insights.

I wish to keep growing until i die and not become a fossilized tree wich stands still.

I think that if i do not physically-mentally impose my will on people i am morally being a good person.
And I have the right to defend myself to survive and reserve the right to take out predators if my life is threatened. that part of Islam i ascribe to.
I do not really need all the other aspects wich for me take up to much energy and time.

I think the Intelligent force wich we call god is just our limited view on something our wildest imagination could not fully appreciate.
And people in history have seen a glimpse of a valid aspect of this intelligence and tried to reform society for the better as i believe most of the prohets of the world have done.

The problem is that after death and codification of the teachings people get stuck and the teachings become a wall in stead of a road that needs to grow to get ahead.

For each time and place a certain teaching can be an improvement but maybe it´s meant to be a phase iinto the next one.

and a lot of teachings of mankind have been very negative and wrong as well , including sjamanism , and some have perverted into dark magic by some force acting in humanity.

iIm wondering why that happens all the time.

I still commend you for your work in exposing negative aspects of your religion as most people dont even see them or dare not to be critical in fear of repression from their peers.

Amar

only Qadyani deny Mahdi and Jesus

All the Sunni groups from salafi to sufi accept Mahdi and Jesus.
Even the shia accept the coming of Mahdi and 2nd coming of Jesus.
There is only 1 group claiming to be Muslim denies Mahdi and 2nd coming of Jesus, and qadyani have never been
Accepted as Muslims their every attempt to label them selves Muslims failed.
In UK the so called relaxed Muslims sufi's are at the forefront of refuting qadyani's.
Please when you give reasons on Islam don't quote botanical encyclopedia quran and hadith are sufficient for us you continue With your belief for us Mahdi and Jesus is part of our belief.

Rev. Sun Myung Moon: gangster, fascist and CIA asset

Given his assocation with Ahmad Kuftaro, it's important to take note of Rev. Moon's involvement with the CIA. Article here: Reverend Moon: Cult leader, CIA asset, and Bush family friend is dead.

Majority of Sunni scholars doubt Mahdi

Despite the popularity of interpretations of the coming of the so-called "Mahdi" among Muslims today, the belief has been regularly condemned by the majority of Sunni scholars. (Shorter Encyclopedia of Islam, 1961, 310ff)

As explained by the Encyclopedia Britannica, "The Qurʾān (Islamic sacred scriptures) does not mention him, and almost no reliable ḥadith (saying attributed to the Prophet Muḥammad) concerning the mahdī can be adduced. Many orthodox Sunni theologians accordingly question Mahdist beliefs, but such beliefs form a necessary part of Shīʿī doctrine."

According to Dr. Fahimi, author of al-Mahdiyya fi al-islam:

"Muhammad bin Isma’il Bukhari and Muslim bin Hajjaj Nishaburi the compilers of the two most authentic books of the Sunni hadith who recorded these traditions meticulously and with extreme caution in verifying their reliability have not included traditions about the Mahdi in their Sihah. Rather these traditions are part of the compilations of Sunan of Abu Dawud Ibn Majah Tirmidhi Nasa’i and Musnad of Ahmad b. Hanbal. These compilers were not careful in selecting traditions and their hadith-reports were regarded by scholars like Ibn Khaldun as weak and unacceptable."(p. 69)

Muwatta Imam Malik the first of famous Hadith books mentions nothing about Mahdi. Even the scholars who beleive that traditions about appearence of Mahdi are true, like the Hanafis, also state that beleif in him being Mahdi is not required as a tenet of belief (Aqeedah).

Also notable is that Ibn Khaldoun, a highly respected historian and social scientist, doubted the appearence of Mahdi and has written a critique of Hadith about Mahdi.

Ibn Khaldun brings twenty one traditions regarding Imam Mahdi, and casts doubt on the narrators and chains of each one of them with these words, “These  are  all the traditions which the scholars bring about Mahdi and his re-appearance at the end of time. You have noticed that all these are doubted, and it is improbable that any has been spared.”

 

source

Where did you get most of that? I could only find links to shi'ite websites.

And as for that Encyclopaedia of Islam a highly orientalist collection enjoyed by the likes of Daniel Pipes et al?

Peace be on him who follows

Peace be on him who follows divine guidance,
This is a warning. Your research is useful, however, in your attempt to differentiate orthodox Islam from universalist/syncretist and more importantly, occult deviance, you often make the foolish mistake of insulting revivers of the Orthodox creed, or denying things which are necessary aspects of Islamic faith, according to the consensus of orthodox Sunni scholars, Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jamah, which you rarely are witnessed quoting from. It is known among scholars and students of Islam that anyone who rejects those things which are known by certain knowledge, meaning that they are mass transmitted hadiths or Quranic verses, or by the consensus of the scholars, is automatically labelled a disbeliever and if found guilty of such a belief will have to renew his faith and his nikah.

1. You have demonstrated reason to doubt the existence of Al Mahdi according to Sunni Orthodoxy in the above paragraph.

2. The evidences you use to deny said belief are inconsequential in regards to principles of Islamic law and theology and the method of establishing evidence (istidlal), and therefore you are in danger of being cast outside the fold of Islam, as whoever denies something known as a necessity of faith is a disbeliever.

Imam Ahmed Rida Khan, a stalwart of orthodox Sunnism and authentic Tasawwuf, who you do not seem to have studied in any serious depth, has quoted in his book refuting a syncretist group which started under the auspices of the Colonial government in British India by the name of Nadwa, and quotes prominent Hanafi scholars to show the verdict concerning one who rejects knowledge known by necessity of the faith. This book book is called Fatawa al Haramayn.

Paragraph Four of the seventh page of the edition printed in Istanbul states: "Whomsoever denies something from the necessities of faith has disbelieved, and whomsoever doubts his disbelief and his inevitable punishment has also disbelieved. There is clear, decisive consensus on this, as mentioned in Fatawa Bazzaziyya, Durr al Mukhtar ofImam Haskafi. Also, it is mentioned in Ash Shifa of Qadi Iyad, Ar Rawda of Imam Nawawi, and al A'lam bi Qawati' ul Islam by Ibn Hajar Makki, that: "There is consensus of the disbelief of one who does not consider a Christian, Jew, or anyone who seperates from the Islamic religion as a disbeliever, or even if he hesitates to make takfir of them or doubts it".

Also, another reviver of the Orthodox tradition, Imam Al Ghazzali states in his book 'Faysal At Tafriqa Baynal Islam waz Zindiqa':

"I say unbelief is taxing the Apostle with lying with reference to anything of that which he brought. And belief is believing him with reference to everything which he brought. There is no takfir on a branch except denial of a basic religious tenet which is known to derive from the Apostle by impeccable tranmission. Taxing with unbelief is obligatory even with branches if they impute lying to the Prophet."

Keeping these principles in mind, the belief in the Mahdi is affirmed by the consensus of the Islamic scholars whose words have weight in matters of faith and law, such as Imam Suyuti and Ibn Hajar Haytami. Imam Suyuti records over 200 hadith in which the Imam Mahdi is mentioned as an inevitable sign of the end of times, therefore, it would be unwise for you to deny something upon which there are so many hadith in favour of your own opinion which is fundamentally lacking understanding of this subject.

Therefore, accept belief in the Mahdi or be cast out of the fold of Islam due to your denial of something known by mutawatir hadith. And no, something does not need to be included within Bukhari and Muslim to be called Mutawatir, and no, just because Bukhari and Muslim used the most stringent methodology in codifying hadith does not mean all other collections are obsolete.

Finally, the Islamic belief in the Mahdi should be accepted because the Prophet mentioned this. However, if you still have doubts after that, know that the Islamic belief in the Mahdi is different from the Zoroastrian 'Saoshyant', is different from the Shiite Imamate concept, and the Mahdi which Muslims await will be a military leader. Also, the messiah awaited by Christians and religio-perennialists is not the same as the Islamic Mahdi, or the Islamic Dajjal, but is a figment of their own imaginations.

In Conclusion, the musings of Pseudo Sufis, and the messianic ravings of perennialists, nor the persian background of the messianic concept are no way near reasons enough to deny a concept depicted in mass narrated traditions of Prophet Muhammad.

Email us for more details. And for a pdf of Imam Suyuti's Al Arf al Wardi Fi Akhbar al Mahdi, in English trans.

"

Who are you

Who are you oh anonymously hiding in the shadow attacking from many angles, what is your name?

"Orthodox tradition, Imam Al Ghazzali ..."

Al Ghazali revived sufism...

another note

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <p> <span> <div> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <img> <map><iframe> <area> <hr> <br> <br /> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <table> <tr> <td> <em> <b> <u> <i> <strong> <font> <del> <ins> <sub> <sup> <quote> <blockquote> <pre> <address> <code> <cite> <embed> <object> <param> <strike> <caption> <embed>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options